Testing in Progress
These foundations are currently undergoing long-term testing in the real world where we’re also testing for wear time. Results will be updated to reflect these insights soon.
It’s no secret that makeup prices are rising quickly. That holds true for all makeup brands, not just high-end and luxury offerings, but if you’re not willing or able to spend a lot of money on makeup, the drugstore is still your best bet. And here’s the thing: Opting for a more budget-friendly option doesn’t mean you’ll need to sacrifice quality or performance. Regarding foundations specifically, plenty of formulas at the drugstore truly rival more expensive offerings.
“You can find a great foundation that works for you at your local drugstore if you know what to look for,” says celebrity makeup artist Sean Harris. “Focus your search on brands that have extensive shade ranges and good coverage and finish options.”
To find the best options, we put more than 20 to test at our lab facility in New York City, evaluating each based on coverage, feel, application, wear, finish, and transfer resistance. From radiant liquid formulas to matte powders and more, here are the ones that impressed us the most.
Best Overall
L'Oréal Paris Fresh Wear Foundation
Buildable coverage
Comes in 40 shades
Contains SPF
Long-wearing with a natural finish
Suitable for all skin types
Watery consistency
Coverage: Medium to full | Shades: 40 | Finish: Natural | Cruelty-Free: No
Drugstore foundations have come a long way in recent years in terms of their formulas and shade ranges, and this one is a prime example of an option that truly rivals high-end and luxury offerings. Available in 40 shades (a massive range compared to most drugstore options) that are nicely dispersed across skin tones and undertones, the liquid consistency is lightweight, buildable, and budge-proof.
One light layer adds a veil of medium coverage, while an additional layer can be applied to achieve a more full-coverage look with a natural finish. We loved how we were able to build it up without it looking too heavy or cakey. The formula also contains SPF 25, which is an added bonus, and it’s resistant to sweat, water, and transfer. When we tested it, we did a transfer test where we gently patted an oil-blotting sheet on the skin to see if any oil or foundation came off—and we were incredibly impressed that nothing transferred onto the paper.
Although we’re currently long-term testing where we’re further evaluating for wear-time, we’re confident that this is a nice long-wearing option thanks to the sweat- and transfer-resistant formula, as well as our editors’ positive experiences wearing it all day long in the past.
Who It’s For
Because of the natural finish and the fact that this formula isn’t too oily or too dry, we think it’s an excellent choice for all skin types. If you’re looking for a foundation with super-buildable coverage, this one is absolutely worth checking out.
Best Full-Coverage
Milani Conceal + Perfect 2-in-1
Buildable coverage
Mousse-like consistency
Easy to blend
Extensive shade range
Oil-free
Comes in 45 shades
Can look heavy on dry patches
Gets a bit greasy on oily skin throughout the day
Coverage: Full | Number of shades: 45 | Finish: Natural | Cruelty-Free: Yes
With a unique mousse-like consistency and incredible buildability, this affordable foundation quickly became a favorite during testing. With one layer, we were able to blend out the formula seamlessly using a brush or a sponge to yield medium coverage that nicely concealed redness. An additional layer allowed us to achieve full coverage that completely blurred the appearance of dark spots and blemishes. We love that it sets down to a natural matte finish that doesn’t look dry or luminous—it’s perfectly in the middle. The mousse-y texture is quite easy to blend, although it is slightly thick and can look heavy if you have dry patches on your skin. To avoid this, we suggest exfoliating and moisturizing prior to application. It’s also worth noting that it can look a bit greasy on oily skin throughout the day, so we recommend setting it in place with powder if you tend to get oily in your T-zone.
Overall, we were very impressed by this foundation. It provides excellent buildable coverage, has a beautiful, natural-looking finish, and comes in 45 shades that range from fair to dark in a variety of undertones.
Who It’s For
This foundation is a great choice for anyone who prefers a full-coverage formula. Although it can look a bit greasy throughout the day, it’s oil-free, making it a fitting option for those with oily or acne-prone skin types who want to avoid pore-clogging oils. We think all skin types can wear this pick so long as you prep and set it accordingly.
Best Long-Wearing
Revlon ColorStay Makeup
Transfer-resistant
Buildable coverage
Lightweight and oil-free
Contains SPF
Skin-like finish
Shade range could be more inclusive
Coverage: Medium to full | Shades: 24 | Finish: Natural | Cruelty-Free: No
Although we’re further testing all of the foundations on this list to get even more insights on wear time over the course of a few months, our initial impressions on the wear of this foundation are absolutely positive. Between tons of online reviews touting its wear time, the sweat-resistant and oil-free formula, and the fact that it didn’t transfer at all during our transfer test at the lab, we’re confident that you’ll get a full day’s wear out of this foundation.
In addition to the budge-proof formula, we loved how buildable it was and how skin-like it looks once it sets down. We were able to get semi-full coverage when layering it up a bit, though it’s nice that just one layer offers medium coverage that lets the skin peek through a bit. The finish is natural with just a hint of glow, and the formula contains hyaluronic acid which helps to keep the skin hydrated.
While there are 24 shades in the range—a decent number compared to other drugstore options—we wish more shades were available for dark skin tones.
Who It’s For
Although the brand recommends it for balanced and dry skin types, we think this foundation is suitable for all skin types since it’s not too matte or too glowy. It’s also oil-free, making it a nice option for acne-prone and oily skin types. If you’re looking for a buildable formula that has good lasting power, we recommend giving this one a go.
Best Powder Formula
e.l.f. Camo Powder Foundation
Feels weightless on the skin
Comes with a sponge applicator
Blurs ski texture
Inclusive shade range
Talc-free
Could be too matte or drying for those with dry skin
Coverage: Buildable | Finish: Satin | Shades: 40 | Cruelty-Free: No
It can be tricky to find powder foundations that offer coverage while not looking cakey—especially at the drugstore—but this one checks the boxes. Offered in 30 shades with a variety of depths and undertones, this pick works to blur the skin texture, even the tone, and temper shine.
During testing, we were impressed by how quickly and easily we were able to apply an even layer to our skin using the sponge included in the packaging. The formula is buildable, so you can apply more to provide more coverage where needed, but we liked that one layer offered medium coverage that maintained a matte, skin-like finish. We were also impressed that even after building it up a bit, it still felt totally breathable and weightless on the skin. Plus, in addition to using it as a foundation, it can also be used as a setting powder to control shine or add additional coverage on top of liquid foundation.
Who It’s For
This powder formula is suitable for all skin types per the brand, though we think it could be a bit too matte and drying if you have extra dry skin. It’s a nice option for anyone who likes to avoid talc in their makeup because talc can be irritating for those with sensitive skin.
Best for Acne-Prone Skin
Almay Clear Complexion Makeup
Formulated with salicylic acid
Lightweight
Fragrance-free
Natural finish
Transfer-resistant
Limited shade range
Coverage: Medium | Shades: 16 | Finish: Natural | Cruelty-Free: No
If you have acne-prone skin, chances are you’re cautious about the skincare and makeup products you use so you don’t trigger breakouts. Not only is this foundation formulated without some potentially irritating ingredients, such as synthetic fragrances and formaldehydes, but it’s also formulated with ingredients that can treat acne, such as salicylic acid and prebiotics.
In addition to loving the ingredients in this formula, we were also truly impressed by how it applied and how it looked on our skin. It offers medium coverage that blurs redness and blemishes without looking cakey or accentuating texture, and the natural matte finish looks extremely skin-like. The liquid formula melted into the skin with ease and felt lightweight and comfortable to wear. We were also impressed that it held up well during our transfer test—only a tiny bit of foundation was visible on the blotting sheet after pressing it against the skin.
The one thing we would change about this foundation is the shade range because it’s limited, especially for deep and dark skin tones.
Who It’s For
This is a fantastic choice for those who deal with breakouts and post-acne marks because of the acne-fighting salicylic acid in the formula and the nice coverage it provides, but we also think it’s great for sensitive skin too thanks to the fragrance-free formula.
Best Liquid for Dark Skin Tones
Black Radiance Color Perfect Oil-Free Liquid
Wide range of deep and dark shades with varying undertones
Buildable
Creamy, blendable texture
Oil-free
Natural finish
Could be more transfer-resistant
Coverage: Full | Shades: 23 | Finish: Natural | Cruelty-Free: Yes
While the beauty industry is getting better at shade inclusivity when it comes to foundation offerings, there’s still more work to be done. Those with deep and dark skin tones often do not have a variety of shades to choose from, which is why brands like Black Radiance are so important. Not only does the shade range of this foundation offer nearly two dozen options for people with deep and dark skin tones in a variety of undertones, but the formula is excellent too.
The liquid consistency is creamy and easy to blend, and we loved how just one pump provided an even layer of full coverage on the skin. It’s not too dewy or too matte, it has a beautiful natural finish with a lightweight, comfortable, and hydrating feel. It did transfer a bit during our transfer test, though we think a setting powder would help to minimize this. But because of the natural finish, hydrating feel on the skin, and oil-free formula, it’s suitable for all skin types.
Who It’s For
If you have deep or dark skin and you’ve struggled to find a foundation at the drugstore that matches your skin tone, we highly recommend checking out this affordable pick from Black Radiance. It has buildable coverage and we think it would work beautifully on dry skin, oily skin, and everything in between.
Best Powder for Dark Skin Tones
BLK/OPL TRUE COLOR Mineral Matte Crème Powder Foundation
Wide range of deep and dark shades with varying undertones
Weightless feel on the skin
Buildable
Skin-like finish
Included sponge isn’t ideal for application
Coverage: Medium | Shades: 12 | Finish: Natural | Cruelty-Free: Yes
Available in 12 shades in deep and dark shades with warm, cool, and neutral undertones, this cream-to-powder formula works to blur the skin while maintaining a skin-like finish. The texture feels like a hard-pressed cream as you apply it, before setting down to a velvety powder finish. It offers medium coverage that can be built up slightly to conceal unevenness in your complexion, and we loved how weightless and undetectable it felt on the skin even after applying a second layer.
We appreciate that it comes with a sponge applicator, though we found it to be too thin and flimsy to apply the product effectively. We recommend applying this formula with a denser sponge or synthetic face brush to get the most evenly distributed coverage. In addition to the shade range and unique, weightless formula, we also like that it contains SPF 15 for a bit of added sun protection.
Who It’s For
This foundation is ideal for people with deep or dark skin tones who crave a weightless texture that offers buildable, but not cakey coverage. It’s not drying nor is it oily, making it a nice option regardless of your skin type.
Best Lightweight
Flower Beauty Serum Foundation
Weightless feel on the skin
Buildable coverage
Natural radiant finish
Good transfer-resistance
Inclusive shade range
Not ideal for applying with a sponge
Coverage: Medium | Finish: Radiant/dewy | Shades: 45 | Cruelty-Free: Yes
Foundations of the past were often thick and heavy on the skin, but thankfully, there are now tons of lightweight options—at the drugstore and on the luxury market—that offer coverage without looking cakey. This one from Flower Beauty is fantastic because it has a liquid, serum-like texture that feels utterly weightless while delivering buildable, natural-looking coverage. During testing, we were incredibly impressed by how stunning the formula looked on the skin. One layer offered light coverage that subtly evened out our skin, while an additional layer helped to cover blemishes and discoloration. Once set down, it had a radiant (but not greasy) finish that allowed some of our natural skin to peek through, making it a beautiful option for daily wear.
While we absolutely loved how weightless this formula felt on the skin, we found that applying it with a sponge wasn’t ideal because the dampened sponge seemed to soak up a lot of the liquid texture. Instead, we recommend applying it with a synthetic foundation brush or your fingertips to maximize the coverage.
Who It’s For
If you’re sensitive to the feeling of heavy foundation sitting on your skin and you’re looking for a lightweight product that offers natural-looking coverage, this is the one for you. Though the shade range isn’t super extensive in terms of the number of shades available, the range is nicely dispersed among fair to dark skin tones, meaning most people will be able to find a shade that works for them. We also think this formula is suitable for all skin types, though those with oily skin will likely want to set it with powder.
Best for No-Makeup Makeup
Maybelline New York Perfector 4-In-1 Makeup
Lightweight with a glowy finish
Multipurpose
Easy to blend
Sponge applicator makes for streaky application
Coverage: Light | Shades: 8 | Finish: Luminous | Cruelty-Free: No
So technically, this product isn’t a foundation. It’s not going to give you much coverage or the capability to conceal redness or blemishes but hear us out. Available in eight flexible shades, it promises to be a primer, concealer, highlighter, and BB cream all in one. It works to give the skin a sheer veil of luminous color, and we were really impressed with it during testing—especially for those who crave a super sheer, glowy look.
While we didn’t like the sponge-tip applicator because it made the formula apply streaky, once blended out with our fingertips or a brush, it looked even and beautiful on the skin. It’s incredibly lightweight and can be applied to bare skin as an all-over wash of color, or on the high points of the face to highlight. It can also be applied on top of foundation for a hint of additional coverage and a glowy finish. Because it doesn’t fully set down, it is a bit tacky to the touch, though it’s not overly sticky and this tackiness thankfully doesn’t lead to a super-greasy finish.
Who It’s For
Whether you’re someone who prefers a no-makeup makeup look or you’re simply on the hunt for an affordable, multipurpose illuminator and foundation to add to your collection, we think this is one worth checking out. If you have dry skin, applying this formula all over can add a healthy-looking glow to your complexion. If you have oily skin, applying it in your T-zone could lead to some excess shine, so we recommend using it as a highlighter on specific places you want to draw attention to.
What to Look for in a Drugstore Foundation
- Formula: Foundations come in various formulas, such as liquids, powders, creams, and sticks. Which one is right for you will largely depend on your skin type and your makeup preferences. Celebrity makeup artist Dominique Della Maggiore recommends first determining your skin type and then selecting a formula accordingly. If you have dry skin, a dewy, hydrating formula will be great for you. If you have oily skin, a powder foundation will help balance excess oil. Some drugstore foundations work especially well for mature skin.
- Shade Range: Finding a foundation shade that matches your complexion is key. “Unfortunately drug stores don't always have the best overhead lighting so I recommend shade matching closer to natural lighting,” says Maggiore. “This can be done near a window in the store. Though this can be costly, do not be afraid of mixing foundation shades together for your desired color.” You’ll know you’ve found the right shade for you when you swatch it on your skin and you can’t detect where it is. “The foundation should disappear into the skin when it’s the right shade for you,” says Harris.
- Coverage: The right coverage for you is ultimately just a matter of preference. If you like a more perfected and even look, opt for something with full coverage. If you prefer to sport a minimal makeup look and just want a subtle hint of coverage, go for a more lightweight, buildable formula.
- Finish: Finish also comes down to your preferences, though your skin type can also play a role in what will work best for you. If you have oily skin, a super dewy foundation can contribute to excess oil, meaning you might want to opt for something with a natural or matte finish. If you have dry skin, a matte finish can emphasize dryness, meaning it’s best to choose something with a natural or radiant finish.
Why Trust Byrdie
Alyssa Kaplan is an experienced writer in the beauty industry and product tester specializing in cosmetics. She’s been using and testing foundations for more than 10 years, and she’s tried several options on this list for herself. She received a bachelor’s degree from the Fashion Institute of Technology, where she studied marketing and product development in the cosmetics industry. Alyssa has been a commerce writer at Byrdie since 2022, where she covers all things beauty.
For this story, Alyssa spoke to experts to discuss important things to consider when looking to purchase drugstore foundations. Those experts include:
- Sean Harris, a celebrity makeup artist based in Los Angeles. He’s worked with clients like Beyonce, Lori Harvey, Liza Koshy, and more.
- Dominique Della Maggiore is a celebrity makeup artist. She’s worked with clients, like Jenna Dewan, Bebe Rexha, and Becky G.